The Stepford Wives: Accept No Substitute

Something strange is happening in the town of Stepford.

Screenwriter William Goldman was less than happy about director Bryan Forbes’s lack of integrity. The filmmaker had cast his wife, Nanette Newman, as one of the seemingly brainwashed Stepford wives. She was not exactly a bombshell, so Forbes decided that the original idea of having those women dress like Playboy bunnies should be abandoned. Instead, the actresses were clad in big-brimmed hats and dresses that covered their bodies. As Goldman argued, if one should stay true to the story there is no way that these women would cover up their bodies. Still, the final results are fun.

I’m writing this review trying not to reveal the film’s secrets (although it may not be much of a secret these days). The story begins with Joanna and Walter Eberhart (Katharine Ross, Peter Masterson) moving out of New York with their two kids. They’re headed to Stepford, Connecticut, a lovely suburb where nothing much happens and good neighbors make friends easily. Joanna is not too comfortable about the move; her husband talked her into it but she does miss the noise of the city. Still, there’s ample opportunity for her to indulge her hobby as a photographer. She finds a new friend, Bobbie Markowe (Paula Prentiss), and together they begin to question women’s lifestyle in Stepford; all their neighbors seem to do is bake and take care of the household, nothing else. And they’re always happy and cheerful, extremely devoted to their husbands. Joanna and Bobbie begin to wonder if there’s something in the water… or if they’re just exaggerating. However, their husbands have joined the Stepford men’s club and they are definitely up to no good. Will Joanna and Bobbie learn what’s going on and be the first women to get out of Stepford safe and sound?

You can see the similarities between this story and author Ira Levin’s previous “Rosemary’s Baby”; both have the central female character sense that something evil is going on and realize that few believe her. The thing is that the filmmakers make sure that we in the audience remain just as uncertain about the signs as Joanna right up until the final sequences when everything is revealed. Some critics complained about the leisurely pace, but that’s nonsense; Forbes creates an environment of fear (even though life in Stepford looks positively sunny) and we’re handed many clues to what’s going on, such as the first sequence where a guy is carrying a mannequin… Sympathy is effectively built for Ross and Prentiss’s characters; they’re both perfect as the only free-spirited women of an oddly conservative society. One of the great things about this film is that it is equally effective as a chiller and a satire on equality and what role women should play in modern marriages; Goldman’s script has several amusing ingredients and funny lines, especially those spoken by Prentiss.

The final sequence is horrifically brilliant. Still, once again I have to question the way the Stepford wives dress; it’s one key factor that is all wrong. Imagine the woman of your fantasies… is it really Anne of Green Gables?

The YouTube clip shows the trailer.

The Stepford Wives 1975-U.S. 115 min. Color. Produced by Edgar J. Scherick. Directed by Bryan Forbes. Screenplay: William Goldman. Novel: Ira Levin. Cast: Katharine Ross (Joanna Eberhart), Paula Prentiss (Bobbie Markowe), Peter Masterson (Walter Eberhart), Nanette Newman, Patrick O’Neal, Tina Louise.

Trivia: Diane Keaton was allegedly considered for the part of Joanna; Brian De Palma for directing duties. Masterson’s daughter, Mary Stuart Masterson, plays his daughter; it is her film debut. Followed by three made-for-TV sequels, starting with Revenge of the Stepford Wives (1980); remade as The Stepford Wives (2004).